
by Shahbod Noori
10/26/2026
From Paris to Italy: When Tolerance Confronts Violence and Hatred
For many people around the world, Europe represents freedom, security, the rule of law, social stability, and respect for human rights. Millions dream of living in countries where they can practice their religion freely, express their opinions without fear of government persecution, and build a better future for their children.
Yet in recent years, Western societies have faced an increasingly serious question:
How should a free society respond to those who benefit from its freedoms while refusing to recognize those same freedoms for others?
This question becomes particularly important when discussing radical Islamist movements—ideologies that reject democracy, equality between women and men, religious freedom, and the separation of religion from government. In their most extreme forms, these movements justify violence as a means of imposing religious and political beliefs.
One distinction must be made absolutely clear: being Muslim does not mean being an extremist. Millions of Muslims live peacefully in Europe and America, respect the law, and are themselves victims of jihadist threats and violence.
The subject of this article is not Islam as a religion or its followers as a whole. It is violent Islamist extremism and the political ideologies that seek to impose their beliefs through intimidation, coercion, and terror.
Paris: A City That Has Repeatedly Faced Extremist Violence
France has paid a devastating price for jihadist terrorism.
The deadly Paris attacks of 2015, the assault on the offices of Charlie Hebdo, the murder of French teacher Samuel Paty, and other acts of violence demonstrated how religious extremism can directly threaten freedom of expression and public safety.
The danger has not disappeared.
French authorities have continued investigating suspected extremist plots and threats against public institutions, Jewish communities, and other potential targets. Investigations into networks allegedly connected to the Iranian government have also raised concerns about efforts to attack American and Jewish interests in Europe.
These are serious developments that cannot be dismissed or ignored.
However, it is equally important to distinguish terrorism from lawful protest and ordinary civil unrest.
Not every demonstration in Paris is connected to Islamist extremism, and not every protester criticizing government policy is a terrorist.
Many French demonstrations have concerned economic hardship, public services, employment, and dissatisfaction with government decisions.
Attributing every disturbance to jihadism would distort reality rather than help us understand it.
Italy and the Rest of Europe: Warnings That Must Be Taken Seriously
Italy has also confronted threats associated with extremist radicalization.
Italian authorities have investigated individuals suspected of involvement in international terrorism, including cases involving online propaganda and alleged connections to ISIS-inspired ideology.
These incidents illustrate an important reality: modern radicalization does not always require attendance at a terrorist training camp or direct contact with an organized militant group.
Today, smartphones, social media platforms, and private online communities can become instruments for spreading extremist propaganda and recruiting vulnerable individuals.
European security assessments have repeatedly identified jihadist terrorism as a major concern, particularly because of its potential to cause mass casualties.
Europol’s reporting on terrorism in the European Union has documented attacks, attempted attacks, disrupted plots, and arrests involving multiple extremist ideologies.
Such warnings deserve serious attention—not to create suspicion toward immigrants or religious communities, but to identify individuals and networks genuinely promoting violence.
The Great Contradiction: Using Freedom to Undermine Freedom
One of the most troubling contradictions of violent extremism is that some of its supporters enjoy the protections of free societies while ideologically rejecting those protections for others.
They may live in countries where they can worship freely, build mosques, establish associations, and publicly express their beliefs.
Yet some defend political systems that punish religious conversion, restrict women’s rights, suppress dissent, or criminalize criticism of religious authorities.
This raises difficult but necessary questions.
How can someone exercise freedom of expression while demanding that opposing voices be silenced?
How can someone benefit from equality under the law while denying equal rights to women or religious minorities?
And how can someone enjoy the protection of a country’s legal system while attempting to justify violence against that country’s citizens?
Freedom must never become a license for intimidation, terrorism, or violence.
At the same time, criticizing America or Europe—even through harsh political slogans—is not automatically a crime or evidence of terrorism.
There is a fundamental difference between peaceful political opposition and incitement to murder, material support for terrorism, or criminal destruction of property.
A free society must understand that difference if it intends to defend its principles.
Jihadist Extremism: A Threat Beyond National Borders
Organizations such as ISIS and al-Qaeda have spent decades attempting to spread their violent ideologies across international borders.
They exploit wars, social instability, perceived injustice, political grievances, and online propaganda to recruit followers.
Within these extremist worldviews, humanity is often divided into enemies and allies, while violence against civilians is sometimes presented as a religious obligation.
But an essential fact is frequently overlooked:
Many victims of jihadist organizations have themselves been Muslims.
From Afghanistan and Iraq to Syria and other parts of the Middle East, ordinary families, women, children, and religious minorities have suffered enormously under extremist violence.
Therefore, confronting jihadism is not simply a matter of defending Europe or the United States.
It is a matter of protecting human life and fundamental freedoms everywhere.
The Islamic Republic and the Export of Ideology
For Iranians who have experienced religious authoritarianism firsthand, this discussion has another important dimension.
For decades, the Islamic Republic has supported armed organizations and networks aligned with its regional political and military objectives.
Investigations into alleged Iranian-linked operations targeting individuals and institutions abroad have increased concerns about the international activities of networks connected to Tehran.
Nevertheless, distinctions are necessary.
Iranian government-backed networks, Sunni jihadist organizations such as ISIS and al-Qaeda, and ordinary Muslim communities are not interchangeable.
These movements do not form a single organization, and some have been bitter enemies of one another.
The dangerous common ground emerges when political or religious ideology is used to justify violence against civilians, suppress individual liberty, or place ideological obedience above basic human rights.
Should Europe Change Its Policies?
In my view, the answer is yes—but those changes must be intelligent, lawful, and firm.
Governments have a fundamental responsibility to protect their citizens.
Careful investigation of credible security threats, prevention of terrorist financing, disruption of online recruitment networks, enforcement of laws against direct incitement to violence, and prosecution of those responsible for terrorist attacks are essential.
No organization should be permitted to use religion as a justification for denying the legal rights of women, children, religious minorities, or nonbelievers.
At the same time, collective punishment of immigrants or discriminatory treatment of law-abiding Muslims would be neither just nor effective.
A society that destroys the freedoms of innocent people in the name of protecting freedom risks sacrificing the very principles it claims to defend.
Security and civil liberties must not be treated as mutually exclusive.
A democratic government should be capable of protecting both.
Final Thoughts: Tolerance Must Never Become Surrender
The free world cannot afford to be naïve about violent extremism.
Respect for religion does not require accepting religious coercion.
Supporting immigrants does not mean overlooking criminal conduct.
Freedom of expression does not provide immunity for threats, intimidation, or incitement to violence.
Democratic countries must defend their laws and values with confidence—not through hatred toward a religion or nationality, but through equal enforcement of the law.
Europe and America are home to millions of people with different religions, beliefs, cultures, and backgrounds.
The strength of these societies lies precisely in their willingness to accept differences while recognizing that no individual, organization, or ideology stands above the law.
Tolerance is a great virtue. But tolerating violence is not a virtue. Freedom must protect human beings—not become a weapon for destroying freedom itself.
And perhaps the most important message of this week’s column is this:
No belief, no flag, and no slogan should ever give anyone the right to sacrifice another person’s life, security, or liberty in the name of a truth that only they claim to possess.
